Chapter 16 - Equality and Civil Rights
Chapter Synopsis
Learning Objectives:
After reading this chapter, students should be able to
· Define the key terms at the end of the chapter
· Distinguish between equality of opportunity and equality of outcome
· Explain why the Civil War Amendments proved ineffective in ensuring racial equality
· Outline the NAACP's strategy for ending school segregation
· Distinguish between de jure and de facto segregation
· Describe the tactics of the civil rights movement and the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act
· Show how protectionist legislation discriminated against women
· List the major legislative and judicial milestones in the struggle for equal rights for women
· Explain why women's rights advocates favored the Equal Rights Amendment rather than the 14th Amendment as a way to extend equal rights to women
· Discuss how affirmative action programs have led to charges of reverse discrimination
Synopsis
This chapter provides a historical overview of the process by which civil and political rights have been extended to African-Americans, women, and other minorities. The search for social and economic equality has been slow and often filled with controversy and violence.
Americans continue to struggle over the difference between equality of opportunity and equality of outcome. While nearly all Americans agree on equality of opportunity, not everyone agrees that individual outcomes should be equal or that society should limit certain individual freedoms in order to ensure that others are "equalized".
The adoption of the 14th, 15th, and 16th Amendments following the Civil War was designed to provide black Americans with the civil and political rights that had been denied to them by slavery. The Supreme Court, however, systematically prevented these citizens from exercising their rights by declaring that the federal government could not regulate private forms of discrimination. Throughout the South, black Americans were denied the right to vote by the use of the poll tax, education requirements, and proof of property ownership.
"Jim Crow" laws, requiring separate housing and public facilities for blacks and whites, became the basis of an official system of racial segregation. In a landmark case, the Supreme Court upheld racially motivated segregation as long as separate but equal facilities were provided for blacks. The Court overlooked the existing differences in facilities available to blacks and whites in reaching this decision. Nevertheless, the separate-but-equal doctrine later allowed black Americans to challenge the discriminatory admissions policies of all white universities.
The political mood of the 1950's favored the successful challenge to the separate-but-equal doctrine in the famous Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka case in 1954. With this decision, the Court approved several remedies, such as busing and racial quotas, to achieve the integration of schools.
The advancement of political equality beyond the classroom, however, required more extensive political mobilization, which came to be known as the Civil Rights movement. During the 1960's, the unconventional political tactics of the civil rights movement, which included boycotts and sit-in demonstrations, brought national attention to the problem of racial discrimination. As a result, Congress passed the Civil Rights act of 1964, the most comprehensive legislation to date designed to eliminate racial discrimination.
Although legislative efforts of Lyndon Johnson's Great Society program did much to improve race relations, the problem of poverty and unemployment among African-Americans in urban areas remained unsolved. This lack of progress toward economic equality was in part responsible for the rise of militant black nationalist movements during the 1960's. Other minorities have had mixed fortunes in improving their lot. Hispanic Latinos have only recently been able to exercise significant economic and political clout in urban areas. Native Americans have had worse treatment. Other non-black ethnic minorities had to wait until 1987, when the Supreme Court extended civil rights protection to them. In 1990, the protection of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was extended to people with disabilities.
The movement toward equal civil rights for women also has a long history of confrontation and struggle. The courts upheld laws discriminating against women in education and employment on the grounds that they protected the "weaker sex" from the harsh realities of life. Women were also "protected" from participating in the electoral process until the adoption of the 19th amendment in 1920. During the 1960's, the prohibition of sex-based discrimination was heralded in the Equal Pay Act of 1963 and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1954. Despite some clear gains in dismantling sexist stereotypes in the work force, most working women are still relegated to jobs that pay less than those held by men. When the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) failed to be ratified by the 1982 deadline, much of the controversy regarding the civil rights of women was put to rest.
One of the more controversial issues the court has dealt with recently concerns affirmative action. The depth of the Court's ambivalence on this issue is illustrated by the 1978 Bakke case, in which the Supreme Court ruled against the use of racial quotas. In 1987, however, in Johnson v. Transportation Agency, Santa Clara County, the Supreme Court upheld the use of affirmative action programs. Overall, the Supreme Court has shown sympathy for the concept of affirmative action while requiring that such practices not deviate excessively from common employment practices. In 1995, however, in Adarand Constructors v. Pena, the court ruled that minority set-aside programs would be subject to "strict scrutiny".
Americans will continue to work through their differences over the competing values of freedom and equality, and many of those debates will occur in the judicial system.
Friday, March 9, 2007
Ch 15 Synopsis
The Challenge of Democracy
Chapter 15 - Order and Civil Liberties
Synopsis
The Bill of Rights and the Constitution give individuals a wide range of civil liberties designed to protect them against the power of the state. The interpretation of how these civil liberties should be enforced has involved a clash between government-imposed order and freedom. The courts, especially the Supreme Court, have the power to resolve societal controversies over values involving civil rights. However, government at all levels can, and does, create rights through laws written by legislatures and regulations issued by bureaucracies.
The First Amendment of the Constitution protects individuals from government laws that interfere with the freedom of religion and freedom of expression. With respect to religion, government has set out to establish a wall of separation between church and state. The Supreme Court has interpreted the establishment clause in the First Amendment in such a way that government is prevented from giving assistance to religious institutions. Over the years, however, indirect and and incidental assistance of parochial schools has been tolerated. Since the Supreme Court handed down its decision in Lemon vs. Kirtzman (1971), state funding of religious programs must pass a stringent test of non-interference with religion. The free exercise clause of the First Amendment protects religious beliefs but not the actions based on those beliefs. Thus, government is allowed to regulate antisocial behavior that stems from a constitutionally protected right.
Freedom of expression is one of the vital characteristics of a democratic system. The freedom of expression clause of the First Amendment confers the right to unrestricted public discourse that does not threaten public order. The Supreme Court has defined the kinds of behavior that constitute a threat to public order through the clear and present danger test. Over the years, the Court has expanded the latitude of political expression that does not present real danger to society. Symbolic expression, such as wearing black armbands to protest the Vietnam War, has been protected by the Court. There are two noted exceptions to freedom of speech. "Fighting words" are defined as utterances designed to "inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace" and are not subject to First Amendment protection. Obscenity is also excluded from constitutional protection.
The First Amendment also guarantees that government will not interfere with freedom of the press. There are limitations on this freedom. Public officials or public figures can institute a lawsuit against the press for libel. The Sullivan case, however, established that "actual malice" must be proved before libel is upheld. Prior restraint, or censorship, is permissible by the government under exceptional circumstances that are not specified by the Court. As demonstrated by the Ellsberg case, the Court takes a very narrow view on what constitutes permissible grounds. Another limitation on freedom of the press exists in the conflict between the needs of law enforcement and those of the free press.
Only with the passing of the Fourteenth Amendment did the Bill of Rights become applicable to the states. The incorporation of the individual guarantees in the Bill of Rights under the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment was a slow, painful process. The landmark decision in Palko vs. Connecticut (1937) interpreted the due process clause to include only "fundamental" rights. In the thirty years after Palko, however, almost every aspect of the Bill of Rights was accepted as a fundamental right.
The incorporation of constitutional procedural safeguards to be used by the states in criminal prosecution has dramatically changed the U.S. criminal justice system in the last thirty years. In several decisions, the Supreme Court required states to provide trial by jury in criminal cases, a lawyer to criminal defendants, the right against self-incrimination through the Miranda warnings, and freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures through the exclusionary rule.
The Supreme Court has expanded the rights of individuals beyond those explicitly enumerated in the Constitution. For instance, the Court has asserted people's right to privacy in making choices about contraception and reproduction. The protection of a woman's decision to have an abortion during the first three months of pregnancy, granted by the Supreme Court in Roe vs. Wade (1973) was the most controversial result of the extension of the right to privacy. Through Webster vs. Reproductive Health Services (1989) and other recent decisions the Court has moved down the road toward greater government control of abortion policy. In addition, in 1986 the Court restricted the right of privacy to only heterosexual choices, thus placing homosexual choices outside constitutional protection. Nonetheless, state-by-state efforts to give homosexual commitments the same status as heterosexual marriage continue to occur.
With the Clinton appointments of Ruth Bader-Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer, the Court may become more moderate in coming years. The judicial branch will continue to play a major role in balancing freedom and order.
Chapter 15 - Order and Civil Liberties
Synopsis
The Bill of Rights and the Constitution give individuals a wide range of civil liberties designed to protect them against the power of the state. The interpretation of how these civil liberties should be enforced has involved a clash between government-imposed order and freedom. The courts, especially the Supreme Court, have the power to resolve societal controversies over values involving civil rights. However, government at all levels can, and does, create rights through laws written by legislatures and regulations issued by bureaucracies.
The First Amendment of the Constitution protects individuals from government laws that interfere with the freedom of religion and freedom of expression. With respect to religion, government has set out to establish a wall of separation between church and state. The Supreme Court has interpreted the establishment clause in the First Amendment in such a way that government is prevented from giving assistance to religious institutions. Over the years, however, indirect and and incidental assistance of parochial schools has been tolerated. Since the Supreme Court handed down its decision in Lemon vs. Kirtzman (1971), state funding of religious programs must pass a stringent test of non-interference with religion. The free exercise clause of the First Amendment protects religious beliefs but not the actions based on those beliefs. Thus, government is allowed to regulate antisocial behavior that stems from a constitutionally protected right.
Freedom of expression is one of the vital characteristics of a democratic system. The freedom of expression clause of the First Amendment confers the right to unrestricted public discourse that does not threaten public order. The Supreme Court has defined the kinds of behavior that constitute a threat to public order through the clear and present danger test. Over the years, the Court has expanded the latitude of political expression that does not present real danger to society. Symbolic expression, such as wearing black armbands to protest the Vietnam War, has been protected by the Court. There are two noted exceptions to freedom of speech. "Fighting words" are defined as utterances designed to "inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace" and are not subject to First Amendment protection. Obscenity is also excluded from constitutional protection.
The First Amendment also guarantees that government will not interfere with freedom of the press. There are limitations on this freedom. Public officials or public figures can institute a lawsuit against the press for libel. The Sullivan case, however, established that "actual malice" must be proved before libel is upheld. Prior restraint, or censorship, is permissible by the government under exceptional circumstances that are not specified by the Court. As demonstrated by the Ellsberg case, the Court takes a very narrow view on what constitutes permissible grounds. Another limitation on freedom of the press exists in the conflict between the needs of law enforcement and those of the free press.
Only with the passing of the Fourteenth Amendment did the Bill of Rights become applicable to the states. The incorporation of the individual guarantees in the Bill of Rights under the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment was a slow, painful process. The landmark decision in Palko vs. Connecticut (1937) interpreted the due process clause to include only "fundamental" rights. In the thirty years after Palko, however, almost every aspect of the Bill of Rights was accepted as a fundamental right.
The incorporation of constitutional procedural safeguards to be used by the states in criminal prosecution has dramatically changed the U.S. criminal justice system in the last thirty years. In several decisions, the Supreme Court required states to provide trial by jury in criminal cases, a lawyer to criminal defendants, the right against self-incrimination through the Miranda warnings, and freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures through the exclusionary rule.
The Supreme Court has expanded the rights of individuals beyond those explicitly enumerated in the Constitution. For instance, the Court has asserted people's right to privacy in making choices about contraception and reproduction. The protection of a woman's decision to have an abortion during the first three months of pregnancy, granted by the Supreme Court in Roe vs. Wade (1973) was the most controversial result of the extension of the right to privacy. Through Webster vs. Reproductive Health Services (1989) and other recent decisions the Court has moved down the road toward greater government control of abortion policy. In addition, in 1986 the Court restricted the right of privacy to only heterosexual choices, thus placing homosexual choices outside constitutional protection. Nonetheless, state-by-state efforts to give homosexual commitments the same status as heterosexual marriage continue to occur.
With the Clinton appointments of Ruth Bader-Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer, the Court may become more moderate in coming years. The judicial branch will continue to play a major role in balancing freedom and order.
Study Guide - Institutions of Government
The Institutions of Government - Study Guide
Chapters 11, 12, 13, & 14
Reapportionment
17th amendment
Redistricting
Shaw v Reno
Miller v Lopez
Line item veto
Congressional Committee system
Floor debate
Ranking minority member
Articles of the Constitution
Inherent power
War Powers Resolution
Presidential popularity over time
George H.W. Bush – vision
America bureaucracy & pluralism
Presidential frustration with the bureaucracy
Administrative discretion
Bureaucratic regulation making
Marbury v. Madison
Clarence Thomas v Anita Hill
Hamilton & Federalist #78
Most criminal offenses are tried at the state level
Statutory construction
Stare decisis
Role of chief justice
Solicitor general
Judicial activism
Judicial restraint
Concurring opinion
Popular election of judges
Senatorial courtesy
Clinton appointed moderates
Rejection of supreme court nominees
Plea bargaining
Class action suits
Chapters 11, 12, 13, & 14
Reapportionment
17th amendment
Redistricting
Shaw v Reno
Miller v Lopez
Line item veto
Congressional Committee system
Floor debate
Ranking minority member
Articles of the Constitution
Inherent power
War Powers Resolution
Presidential popularity over time
George H.W. Bush – vision
America bureaucracy & pluralism
Presidential frustration with the bureaucracy
Administrative discretion
Bureaucratic regulation making
Marbury v. Madison
Clarence Thomas v Anita Hill
Hamilton & Federalist #78
Most criminal offenses are tried at the state level
Statutory construction
Stare decisis
Role of chief justice
Solicitor general
Judicial activism
Judicial restraint
Concurring opinion
Popular election of judges
Senatorial courtesy
Clinton appointed moderates
Rejection of supreme court nominees
Plea bargaining
Class action suits
Friday, March 2, 2007
Ch 14 - Synopsis
Ch 14 Synopsis
The Constitution created only one court – the Supreme Court – and sketched the rough contours of federal judicial power. The real design took shape in the first Congress, and much of the handiwork can be seen in today’s court system. Congress created federal (national) courts that would co-exist with the courts in each state but would be independent of them. But the judiciary was not viewed as a powerful branch of government until John Marshall was appointed the third Chief Justice in 1803.
Marshall’s opinion in Marbury v Madison (1803) established the power of judicial review, the power to declare acts of coordinate branches (and acts of state government) void because they violate the Constitution. This power appears to conflict with democratic theory because an unelected branch can trump an elected branch in the name of the Constitution.
The federal courts form a hierarchy, with the Supreme Court at the apex, the courts of appeal in the middle, and the district courts at the base. Note that most litigation arises in state courts; federal courts have limited jurisdiction to decide civil and criminal cases. Policymaking in the courts occurs at all levels, but it is most pronounced in appellate courts, where the emphasis on judicial opinions enables judges to create precedents.
The Supreme Court deserves special consideration because the value conflicts inherent in American democracy often end up before the court’s nine justices. The Court is a national policymaker with far-reaching impact. The Court exercises influence in part through the power to set its own agenda; it is aided in this function by the solicitor general, who represents the federal government before the Court.
If presidents are successful in appointing judges who share their values, they can influence policy even after their term is over. Although this is true across the federal judiciary, it is especially pronounced for appointments to the Supreme Court. Judges (some more than others) exercise political power. Separation of powers and checks and balances frustrate representative government. Groups that failed to secure or protect their interests in then democratic branches can turn to lawyers and the courts. Pluralist democracy operates when groups press their interests on the government. The open access provided by the courts reinforces pluralist democracy.
Though judicial power runs counter to democratic theory, policies emanating from the Supreme Court rarely seem pout of step with majority sentiment or the trend toward such sentiment. There are some exceptions to this observation, such as the Roe v. Wade abortion decision. Recent decisions and changes in the Court presage a change on the abortion issue, however, perhaps one closer in step with majority views.
Judges confront new issues calling for the exercise of judicial power. With open access to the judiciary and the creation of new rights in the name of the Constitution, courts increasingly become arenas in the conflicts between freedom and order and between freedom and equality.
The Constitution created only one court – the Supreme Court – and sketched the rough contours of federal judicial power. The real design took shape in the first Congress, and much of the handiwork can be seen in today’s court system. Congress created federal (national) courts that would co-exist with the courts in each state but would be independent of them. But the judiciary was not viewed as a powerful branch of government until John Marshall was appointed the third Chief Justice in 1803.
Marshall’s opinion in Marbury v Madison (1803) established the power of judicial review, the power to declare acts of coordinate branches (and acts of state government) void because they violate the Constitution. This power appears to conflict with democratic theory because an unelected branch can trump an elected branch in the name of the Constitution.
The federal courts form a hierarchy, with the Supreme Court at the apex, the courts of appeal in the middle, and the district courts at the base. Note that most litigation arises in state courts; federal courts have limited jurisdiction to decide civil and criminal cases. Policymaking in the courts occurs at all levels, but it is most pronounced in appellate courts, where the emphasis on judicial opinions enables judges to create precedents.
The Supreme Court deserves special consideration because the value conflicts inherent in American democracy often end up before the court’s nine justices. The Court is a national policymaker with far-reaching impact. The Court exercises influence in part through the power to set its own agenda; it is aided in this function by the solicitor general, who represents the federal government before the Court.
If presidents are successful in appointing judges who share their values, they can influence policy even after their term is over. Although this is true across the federal judiciary, it is especially pronounced for appointments to the Supreme Court. Judges (some more than others) exercise political power. Separation of powers and checks and balances frustrate representative government. Groups that failed to secure or protect their interests in then democratic branches can turn to lawyers and the courts. Pluralist democracy operates when groups press their interests on the government. The open access provided by the courts reinforces pluralist democracy.
Though judicial power runs counter to democratic theory, policies emanating from the Supreme Court rarely seem pout of step with majority sentiment or the trend toward such sentiment. There are some exceptions to this observation, such as the Roe v. Wade abortion decision. Recent decisions and changes in the Court presage a change on the abortion issue, however, perhaps one closer in step with majority views.
Judges confront new issues calling for the exercise of judicial power. With open access to the judiciary and the creation of new rights in the name of the Constitution, courts increasingly become arenas in the conflicts between freedom and order and between freedom and equality.
Saturday, January 27, 2007
Government Leadership
United States Government Leadership
1. President - George W. Bush
2. Vice-President – Dick Cheney
3. National Security Adviser - Stephen Hadley
4. White House Chief of Staff - Josh Bolten
5. Senior Political Adviser - Karl Rove
6. Secretary of State - Condoleeza Rice
7. Secretary of Defense - Robert Gates
8. Secretary of the Treasury - Henry Paulson, Jr.
9. Attorney General - Alberto Gonzales
10. Secretary of Homeland Security - Michael Chertoff
11. Director of the FBI - Robert Mueller
12. Director of CIA - Gen. Michael Hayden
13. Senate Majority Leader - Harry Reid – D – Nevada
14. Senate Majority Whip - Dick Durbin – D – Illinois
15. Senate Minority Leader - Mitch McConnell – R – Kentucky
16. Senate Minority Whip - Trent Lott – R – Mississippi
17. President Pro Tempore - Robert Byrd – D – West Virginia
18. Speaker of the House - Nancy Pelosi – D- California
19. House Majority Leader - Stenny Hoyer – D – Maryland
20. House Majority Whip - James Clyburn – D – South Carolina
21. House Minority Leader - John Boehner – R – Ohio
22. House Minority Whip - Roy Blunt – R - Missouri
1. President - George W. Bush
2. Vice-President – Dick Cheney
3. National Security Adviser - Stephen Hadley
4. White House Chief of Staff - Josh Bolten
5. Senior Political Adviser - Karl Rove
6. Secretary of State - Condoleeza Rice
7. Secretary of Defense - Robert Gates
8. Secretary of the Treasury - Henry Paulson, Jr.
9. Attorney General - Alberto Gonzales
10. Secretary of Homeland Security - Michael Chertoff
11. Director of the FBI - Robert Mueller
12. Director of CIA - Gen. Michael Hayden
13. Senate Majority Leader - Harry Reid – D – Nevada
14. Senate Majority Whip - Dick Durbin – D – Illinois
15. Senate Minority Leader - Mitch McConnell – R – Kentucky
16. Senate Minority Whip - Trent Lott – R – Mississippi
17. President Pro Tempore - Robert Byrd – D – West Virginia
18. Speaker of the House - Nancy Pelosi – D- California
19. House Majority Leader - Stenny Hoyer – D – Maryland
20. House Majority Whip - James Clyburn – D – South Carolina
21. House Minority Leader - John Boehner – R – Ohio
22. House Minority Whip - Roy Blunt – R - Missouri
Wednesday, January 17, 2007
Mid-Term Study Guide
* objectives of government
* equality of opportunity/equality of outcome
* autocracies/oligarchies/democracies
* substantive democracy
* procedural democracy
* main argument against the need for a bill of rights
* Marbury v Madison
* federalism(dual/cooperative)
* sovereignty
* McCulloch v Maryland
* public opinion
* polling/distribution
* party identification
* political socialization
* mass media
* functions of mass media
* "horse race" journalism
* journalistic "spin"
* conventional political participation
* unconventional political participation
* class action suit
* 13th,14th,15th amendments
* referendum
* education and voter turnout
* voter registration laws
* voter turnout
* political parties
* elections
*
* equality of opportunity/equality of outcome
* autocracies/oligarchies/democracies
* substantive democracy
* procedural democracy
* main argument against the need for a bill of rights
* Marbury v Madison
* federalism(dual/cooperative)
* sovereignty
* McCulloch v Maryland
* public opinion
* polling/distribution
* party identification
* political socialization
* mass media
* functions of mass media
* "horse race" journalism
* journalistic "spin"
* conventional political participation
* unconventional political participation
* class action suit
* 13th,14th,15th amendments
* referendum
* education and voter turnout
* voter registration laws
* voter turnout
* political parties
* elections
*
Friday, January 5, 2007
Chapter 10 Notes
Chapter 10 – Interest Groups
Learning Objectives
After reading this chapter, students should be able to:
Define the key terms at the end of the chapter
Outline the positive and negative roles played by interest groups in American politics.
Explain how interest groups form
Create a profile of the kind of person most likely to be represented by an interest group.
Describe the major resources interest groups use in their efforts to influence policy.
List the tactics used by interest groups to win the support of policymakers.
Account for the recent increase in the number of interest groups.
Discuss the difficulties involved in trying to reform the role of interest groups in American politics.
Chapter Synopsis
The existence of interest groups represents a fundamental dilemma for the American political system. Interest groups work to gain advantages for themselves at the expense of the larger population. Indeed, Madison warned that “factions” would go as far as to suppress the rights of others to achieve their objectives. Yet interest groups are a manifestation of liberty; curbing interest groups means curbing freedom.
Interest groups do play many positive roles. Among other things, they represent people before their government. Yet a troubling aspect of interest group politics has to do with the nature of this representation. Some segments of society (particularly the wealthy, well educated, and businesses) are more likely to be represented by lobbying organizations than other constituencies are. This inequity is also manifested in the resources available to groups.
In recent years we have observed an upsurge in the number of interest groups. The most troubling aspect of that growth is the increasingly significant role political action committees, or PAC’s play in financing congressional elections. The greatest portion of PAC contributions come from corporate PAC’s. Critics charge that PAC’s gain undue advantage from the access they gain with contributions. They argue that PAC’s exacerbate the inequities in American society. Defenders respond that PAC’s are a way in which people can participate in politics. Moreover, shouldn’t people have the freedom to join together with other like-minded Americans to promote the candidates they believe in?
Parallel Lecture:
An interest group can be defined as “an organized body of individuals who share some political goals and try to influence public policy”.
Roles of Interest Groups:
Representation: interest groups represent their constituents before government
Participation: they facilitate people’s participation in politics
Education: efforts made by interest groups help to educate their members, the public at large, and government officials
Agenda Building: news issues are brought onto the political agenda through interest group advocacy
Program monitoring: Lobbying organizations keep track of how programs are working in the field and try to persuade government to take action when problems become evident
Interest group formation:
Pluralists such as David Truman see interest groups naturally forming when people are adversely affected by a disturbance
Yet some people who are adversely affected do not organize
Political Scientist Robert Salisbury argues that the quality of leadership is a key determinant of successful interest group formation
He sees an interest group leader as an entrepreneur. The entrepreneur must convince potential members that there are compelling reasons to join the group.
Who is being organized is also an important force affecting group formation. The wealthy and well-educated are more likely to form and join lobbies.
Resources:
One of the most valuable resources a group can have is a large and politically active membership
Business, professional, and trade associations have an easier time holding onto members than citizen groups do.
A citizen group must rely largely on ideological appeals. Many try to attract new members through direct mail (e-mail)
Free-rider problem: non-members can obtain the public policy benefits of the organization’s lobbying even though they pay no dues
Lobbyists can be either full-time employees of the organization, or hired from law firms or public relations firms.
The typical interaction between a lobbyist and a policymaker is the transmission of information from the lobbyist to the official
Political Action Committees pool contributions from group members and donate those funds to candidates for office
Two types of PAC’s have shown the greatest growth in numbers
Corporate PAC’s
Non-Connected PAC’s (ideological PAC’s formed solely for channeling funds)
The primary goal of PAC’s is to gain access to incumbents
The role of PAC’s in financing elections has become the most controversial aspect of interest group politics
In Direct lobbying, a group’s representatives have direct contact with a policymaker
Lobbyists make personal presentations
Testifying before committees is another direct tactic
Organizations may go to court and litigate
In grassroots lobbying, an interest group’s rank and file members, and possibly others outside the organization, try to influence government on some issue
Letter writing is one such tactic
Political protests are sometimes held
Information campaigns are organized efforts to gain public backing by bringing the group’s views to the public’s attention
newspaper advertising, sending speaker’s to meetings, disseminating pamphlets or fact sheets
sponsoring research
some groups publicize the voting records of Congress
Coalition Building takes place when several groups join together in a lobbying campaign
Lobbying must be evaluated through the pluralist and majoritarian frameworks
Lobbying reinforces the pluralist definition of who has power in policymaking
However, since elections are majoritarian, the party in power tends to have more say in policymaking
One problem is membership bias – some types of people (middle class & upper middle classes) are far better represented by organized interest groups
Lower-income people tend to be represented by issue-oriented lobbies whose members are not poor but whose policy positions address the problems of the poor
Public interest groups are those that have no economic self-interest in the policies they pursue
Common Cause pushes for good government legislation
public interest groups can be liberal or conservative
the number of business lobbies has increased significantly
Both the number of trade associations and the number of corporate offices located in Washington, DC has gone up sharply
The growth of federal regulation is one reason the number of business lobbies is growing
Access: while govt. officials may limit access by certain interest groups, other officials, with differing ideologies, keep the door open
However, all forms of access are not equally useful to interest groups, and some groups have better access over time.
Reform: it is difficult to put limits on interest groups without limiting fundamental freedoms
More recently, Congress has required disclosure of all campaign contributions so sources can be identified
In 1995, Congress passed a law requiring lobbyists to register and file semi-annual reports disclosing their clients, the amount of money they spent on lobbying activities, and the amount of money they were paid
Reformers have called for reducing the role of PAC’s in financing elections
The controversy over PAC’s reflects the tension between the principles of freedom and equality
Critics charge that PAC’s reinforce, if not expand, the inequities between rich and poor
PAC supporters counter that people should have the right to join with others who think as they do and support the candidates of their choice
Learning Objectives
After reading this chapter, students should be able to:
Define the key terms at the end of the chapter
Outline the positive and negative roles played by interest groups in American politics.
Explain how interest groups form
Create a profile of the kind of person most likely to be represented by an interest group.
Describe the major resources interest groups use in their efforts to influence policy.
List the tactics used by interest groups to win the support of policymakers.
Account for the recent increase in the number of interest groups.
Discuss the difficulties involved in trying to reform the role of interest groups in American politics.
Chapter Synopsis
The existence of interest groups represents a fundamental dilemma for the American political system. Interest groups work to gain advantages for themselves at the expense of the larger population. Indeed, Madison warned that “factions” would go as far as to suppress the rights of others to achieve their objectives. Yet interest groups are a manifestation of liberty; curbing interest groups means curbing freedom.
Interest groups do play many positive roles. Among other things, they represent people before their government. Yet a troubling aspect of interest group politics has to do with the nature of this representation. Some segments of society (particularly the wealthy, well educated, and businesses) are more likely to be represented by lobbying organizations than other constituencies are. This inequity is also manifested in the resources available to groups.
In recent years we have observed an upsurge in the number of interest groups. The most troubling aspect of that growth is the increasingly significant role political action committees, or PAC’s play in financing congressional elections. The greatest portion of PAC contributions come from corporate PAC’s. Critics charge that PAC’s gain undue advantage from the access they gain with contributions. They argue that PAC’s exacerbate the inequities in American society. Defenders respond that PAC’s are a way in which people can participate in politics. Moreover, shouldn’t people have the freedom to join together with other like-minded Americans to promote the candidates they believe in?
Parallel Lecture:
An interest group can be defined as “an organized body of individuals who share some political goals and try to influence public policy”.
Roles of Interest Groups:
Representation: interest groups represent their constituents before government
Participation: they facilitate people’s participation in politics
Education: efforts made by interest groups help to educate their members, the public at large, and government officials
Agenda Building: news issues are brought onto the political agenda through interest group advocacy
Program monitoring: Lobbying organizations keep track of how programs are working in the field and try to persuade government to take action when problems become evident
Interest group formation:
Pluralists such as David Truman see interest groups naturally forming when people are adversely affected by a disturbance
Yet some people who are adversely affected do not organize
Political Scientist Robert Salisbury argues that the quality of leadership is a key determinant of successful interest group formation
He sees an interest group leader as an entrepreneur. The entrepreneur must convince potential members that there are compelling reasons to join the group.
Who is being organized is also an important force affecting group formation. The wealthy and well-educated are more likely to form and join lobbies.
Resources:
One of the most valuable resources a group can have is a large and politically active membership
Business, professional, and trade associations have an easier time holding onto members than citizen groups do.
A citizen group must rely largely on ideological appeals. Many try to attract new members through direct mail (e-mail)
Free-rider problem: non-members can obtain the public policy benefits of the organization’s lobbying even though they pay no dues
Lobbyists can be either full-time employees of the organization, or hired from law firms or public relations firms.
The typical interaction between a lobbyist and a policymaker is the transmission of information from the lobbyist to the official
Political Action Committees pool contributions from group members and donate those funds to candidates for office
Two types of PAC’s have shown the greatest growth in numbers
Corporate PAC’s
Non-Connected PAC’s (ideological PAC’s formed solely for channeling funds)
The primary goal of PAC’s is to gain access to incumbents
The role of PAC’s in financing elections has become the most controversial aspect of interest group politics
In Direct lobbying, a group’s representatives have direct contact with a policymaker
Lobbyists make personal presentations
Testifying before committees is another direct tactic
Organizations may go to court and litigate
In grassroots lobbying, an interest group’s rank and file members, and possibly others outside the organization, try to influence government on some issue
Letter writing is one such tactic
Political protests are sometimes held
Information campaigns are organized efforts to gain public backing by bringing the group’s views to the public’s attention
newspaper advertising, sending speaker’s to meetings, disseminating pamphlets or fact sheets
sponsoring research
some groups publicize the voting records of Congress
Coalition Building takes place when several groups join together in a lobbying campaign
Lobbying must be evaluated through the pluralist and majoritarian frameworks
Lobbying reinforces the pluralist definition of who has power in policymaking
However, since elections are majoritarian, the party in power tends to have more say in policymaking
One problem is membership bias – some types of people (middle class & upper middle classes) are far better represented by organized interest groups
Lower-income people tend to be represented by issue-oriented lobbies whose members are not poor but whose policy positions address the problems of the poor
Public interest groups are those that have no economic self-interest in the policies they pursue
Common Cause pushes for good government legislation
public interest groups can be liberal or conservative
the number of business lobbies has increased significantly
Both the number of trade associations and the number of corporate offices located in Washington, DC has gone up sharply
The growth of federal regulation is one reason the number of business lobbies is growing
Access: while govt. officials may limit access by certain interest groups, other officials, with differing ideologies, keep the door open
However, all forms of access are not equally useful to interest groups, and some groups have better access over time.
Reform: it is difficult to put limits on interest groups without limiting fundamental freedoms
More recently, Congress has required disclosure of all campaign contributions so sources can be identified
In 1995, Congress passed a law requiring lobbyists to register and file semi-annual reports disclosing their clients, the amount of money they spent on lobbying activities, and the amount of money they were paid
Reformers have called for reducing the role of PAC’s in financing elections
The controversy over PAC’s reflects the tension between the principles of freedom and equality
Critics charge that PAC’s reinforce, if not expand, the inequities between rich and poor
PAC supporters counter that people should have the right to join with others who think as they do and support the candidates of their choice
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)